A groundbreaking study by political scientists Martin Gilens and Benjamin I. Page challenges the notion of American democracy as a system of government that is truly representative of its citizens. The study, published in the American Political Science Review, found that economic elites and organized interest groups have a much greater impact on policy decisions than average citizens. The researchers analyzed over 1,800 policy decisions and concluded that the preferences of the wealthy and powerful have a disproportionate influence on the direction of the country, while the desires of the majority of citizens have little to no impact. The study’s findings raise serious concerns about the state of American democracy and the extent to which it truly represents the interests of the people.
The study’s findings suggest that policies are designed primarily to benefit the wealthy and powerful, leading to a widening income gap and policies that are harmful to public health. This has contributed to a decline in public trust in government institutions, with citizens feeling that their voices are not being heard. One example of this is the 2017 tax overhaul, which largely benefited wealthy individuals and corporations despite widespread public opposition. The bill was pushed through by Republican lawmakers with the support of wealthy donors and corporate lobbyists, resulting in a significant increase in the federal budget deficit and a decrease in government revenue.
There are several other examples of public policy that have been influenced by economic elites and interest groups in ways that may not align with the interests of the general public.
One example is the recent deregulation of the financial industry, which many experts believe contributed to the 2008 financial crisis. Prior to the crisis, major financial institutions had lobbied for the repeal of laws that had been put in place to prevent the type of risky lending and investing practices that ultimately led to the crisis.
Another example is the pharmaceutical industry’s influence on healthcare policy. The high cost of prescription drugs in the United States can be attributed, in part, to the influence of the pharmaceutical industry on policy decisions. For example, the industry has used its lobbying power to prevent the government from negotiating drug prices with manufacturers, which has resulted in Americans paying significantly more for medications than people in other countries.
The gun lobby’s influence on gun control policy is another example. Despite widespread support for measures such as background checks and limits on assault weapons, the gun lobby’s political influence has prevented meaningful action on gun control at the federal level.
These findings raise serious concerns about the state of American democracy and the extent to which it represents the interests of the people.
How Can We Change This?
You’ve made the first step by visiting New Wall Street. The second step? Organizing. As individuals, we hold little power, but as a collective we can move mountains. Join the tribe to make a difference.
What Else Should You Know?
The influence of economic elites and interest groups on public policy is a widespread and longstanding issue, both in the United States and around the world, according to experts. While scholars have been debating this issue for decades, there is ongoing discussion about the extent to which these groups actually drive policy decisions. Some argue that their influence is overstated, while others maintain that it is a pervasive and harmful problem that needs to be addressed.
To combat this issue, various solutions have been proposed, including campaign finance reform, increased transparency and accountability in the political process, and giving more voice to marginalized groups in the policy-making process. However, finding effective solutions to address the outsized influence of economic elites and interest groups remains a complex challenge.
The issue is not limited to a particular policy area, but rather can be seen in various domains such as the financial industry, healthcare policy, and gun control. The pharmaceutical industry’s lobbying power, for example, has prevented the government from negotiating drug prices with manufacturers, resulting in high prescription drug costs for Americans. The gun lobby’s political influence, on the other hand, has prevented meaningful action on gun control at the federal level despite widespread public support for certain measures.
Overall, the influence of economic elites and interest groups on public policy is a critical issue that raises important questions about the role of democratic systems and the role of government in promoting the common good.